Cocoa Butter vs Shea Butter

Jergens® Skincare Team:
:

Smooth Skin

 
Cocoa Butter vs. Shea Butter

Learn the difference between these two top skincare ingredients.

Determined to get rid of your dry skin, you decide it’s time to add something to your skincare routine that will actually work. But, you find yourself standing in the aisle, unsure if you should choose a cocoa butter or shea butter product. If this sounds at all familiar to you, a few key considerations can help you finally choose a product and begin repairing your dry skin.

Cocoa butter and shea butter are nourishing skincare ingredients that are known to help your skin feel healthy and smooth. These butters provide long-lasting moisture and can become an integral part of your skincare routine. Shea butter is an excellent source of vitamin A and vitamin E, which help moisturize your skin and help prevent signs of skin aging. Cocoa butter has a high fat content, which helps create a protective barrier over your skin. When deciding which ingredient is best for you, a few key factors may impact your decision.

"Shea butter is an excellent source of vitamin A and vitamin E, which help moisturize your skin and help prevent signs of skin aging. Cocoa butter has a high fat content, which helps create a protective barrier over your skin."

Key Differences Between Shea Butter and Cocoa Butter

Both shea butter and cocoa butter are plant-based fats that moisturize your skin and are a good solution to dry skin. They also both melt on-contact with your skin.

The main difference between shea butter and cocoa butter is that shea butter comes from the nuts of a shea tree while cocoa butter comes from cocoa beans. But, they have some other key differences that can help you decide which you want to use.

Shea Butter vs Cocoa Butter

Shea Butter Cocoa
Smell Slightly nutty and smokey Light chocolate scent
Appearance Creamy, ivory for unrefined Browner tint
Origin Africa 
Fat extracted from nuts of shea tree and churned into butter 
South/Central Africa
Extracted from cocoa beans
Fatty Acids Linoleic acid
Arachidic acid
Palmitic acid
Oleic acid
Stearic acid
Palmitic acid
Primary Benefit Contains vitamins A and E
Reduce uneven skin tone
Reduce dry skin damage
Nourish skin
Create protective barrier to prevent moisture loss

Cocoa Butter vs. Shea Butter: Which Should I Choose?

If you have dry skin, moisturizers infused with shea butter or cocoa butter are great options for improving the look and feel of your skin. Here are a few things to consider when deciding between shea butter and cocoa butter:

Shea Butter May Be Better for Acne-Prone Skin

If your skin is prone to acne and other blemishes, you may want to choose shea butter over cocoa butter. Cocoa butter is slightly thicker than shea butter so it may clog your pores.
Although shea butter is rich and luxurious, it is actually lightweight on your skin! If your skin is extra dry, try a deep conditioning shea butter to nourish your skin and improve common dry spots like your knees and elbows.

Cocoa Butter for Aromatherapy

If you’re interested in adding aromatherapy into your daily skincare routine, cocoa butter might be for you! Cocoa butter is commonly used during massages because it has a distinct chocolate aroma that can be relaxing and comforting.
Plus, you’ll get the moisturizing your skin craves at the same time.

Shea Butter is Known to Improve the Appearance of Stretch Marks

Shea butter is also known to improve stretch marks and other skin blemishes. Shea butter is a natural source of vitamin A and vitamin E, so it can help reduce the appearance of stretch marks and skin blemishes.

Sometimes You Don’t Have to Choose!

Some dry skin moisturizers use unique blends of cocoa butter and shea butter, so you can get the best of both these ingredients. Our body butters use a combination of Shea, Cocoa, and Mango Butters to create an ultra-hydrating formula to deeply nourish your skin. This combination results in a luxurious moisturizer that refreshes and smooths your skin.

Is Shea Butter or Cocoa Butter Best?

When finding the best ingredients for your skin, the most important factor is your skin goals. If you’re looking to moisturize your skin and protect it against daily dryness, both shea butter and cocoa butter provide similar benefits.

Since both are good sources of moisture, give them each a try and see which one you enjoy the most. Or, try our body butters, like this refreshing Eucalyptus Mint, which are an ultra-hydrating combination of cocoa, shea, and mango butters. In the end, you can’t really go wrong!

Key Takeaways

  • Cocoa butter is made from cocoa beans while shea butter is made from the nut of shea trees.

  • If you have acne-prone skin, shea butter might be a better choice because it is lightweight.

  • Cocoa butter is commonly used during massages due to its calming aroma.

  • Shea butter is known to improve stretch marks and other skin blemishes.

  • In the end, both kinds of butter can help moisturize your skin.

Related Articles

Discover the differences between body butter and lotion to see which one is best for your skin!

Use our skincare tips to achieve luminous, healthy-looking skin.

From shower tips to daily moisturizing, we’ll show you how to get visibly softer and more radiant skin.
Page Top